USDA Organic

HACCP

SQF3

Non-GMO Project

Locally Certified Kosher

RSPO Identity Preserved

Canada

United States

Distributor

Conventional (Non-GMO)

Organic

Our mission is to produce superior products for our customers. We are committed to sustainability and we spread integrity. A chance question from a friend, “You have a barrel roaster; why don’t you use it to make peanut butter?” led our co-founders to the peanut butter business. In 1976, Once Again Nut Butter was born. When Jeremy and Connie left Rochester for a more rural area, they moved the company into their 800-square foot basement and manufactured peanut butter there until they purchased the current facility in 1981.

Once Again

Sesame tahini is made with lightly roasted sesame seeds and milled to produce sesame tahini. Oil separation occurs naturally. 

Available in 9 lb and 35 lb tubs and 12 x 16 oz

Sesame Tahini

We offer whole dry roasted almonds in 10lb and 25lb options, both organic and conventional.

We also have a dry roasted Tamari almond available.



Roasted Almonds

Our line of natural and organic cashew butter products are made through the process of milling. Using 5%-8% expeller-pressed safflower oil, we’re able to create a spreadable and tasty treat. Oil separation may occur naturally with our organic cashew butter. To prevent this, stir and refrigerate or freeze.

Available in 9 lb and 35 lb tubs and 12 x 16 oz

Cashew Butter

Sunflower seed butter is made by roasting organically grown sunflower seeds. The seeds are milled creamy with sugar, a little bit of oil and salt. 

We have two versions of this that we produce.  One has sugar, salt and oil and one is sugar and salt free. The salt we use is iodized salt and the sugar we use is organic evaporated cane juice. The oil that is added to this product is organic high oleic sunflower oil.

Organic Sunflower Butter
Organic Sunflower Butter – No Sugar / No Salt

Available in 9 lb tub and 12 x 16 oz

Sunflower Butter

We use the finest unblanched almonds and mill them to a creamy perfection. We dry our almonds lightly to preserve the naturally sweet flavor of toasted almonds.

Available in 9 lb and 35 lb tubs and 12 x 16 oz

American Classic Almond Butter – Creamy (No Stir)
Almond Butter – Crunchy
Almond Butter – Creamy
Almond Butter – Lightly Toasted – Creamy

Organic Almond Butter – Creamy
Organic Almond Butter – Lightly Toasted – Crunchy
Organic Almond Butter – Lightly Toasted – Creamy

Once Again

100% employee owned